README: This is just my opinion, so please don’t take offense if this is your absolute favorite #1 product ever.
Products work differently for different people!
I bought my bottle of Simple Eye Make-up Remover at Bed Bath & Beyond for $6.99, and my Sephora Waterproof Eye Makeup Remover was $9.99. They contain the same amt of the product. The Sephora remover is water/silicone based.
Products from Amazon.com
Price: $6.98Was: $8.89
Price: $12.24Was: $15.00
Price: $6.74Was: $8.99
Price: $16.98Was: $18.00
Price: $6.69Was: $8.89
If you have truly sensitive skin (skin that is highly reactive to ingredients, esp. dyes, and fragrances), and can’t use regular makeup removers, then this may be a good option for you, particularly since you probably can’t use most cosmetics anyway.
However, as most people do not have type-sensitive skin, I don’t think that all the rubbing of your eyes will make having a gentler product worthwhile.